Building a Garment Quality Framework
Effective quality control requires a systematic approach from product development through final shipment.
Quality Control Stages
- Pre-production: Sample approval, material testing, production readiness
- During production: In-line inspections to catch issues early
- Pre-shipment: Final random inspection before shipping
- Post-arrival: Spot checks at destination (optional)
Quality Specification Development
Clear specifications prevent disputes and ensure consistency:
- Tech pack: Detailed construction specifications
- Size specifications: Measurements with tolerances
- Material specifications: Fabric weight, hand feel, color standards
- Workmanship standards: Acceptable stitch density, seam allowances, etc.
- Packaging specifications: Folding, hangers, tags, poly bags
Approved Samples
Maintain approved samples for reference:
- Pre-production sample: Final approved sample before production
- Production sample: First production unit for verification
- Counter sample: Left with factory for reference during production
- Shipment sample: Random pull from each shipment for records
Types of Quality Inspections
Different inspection types serve different purposes. A comprehensive QC program uses multiple inspection points.
Pre-Production Inspection
Before production begins, verify:
- Raw materials meet specifications
- Trims, labels, and packaging are correct
- Production samples match approved samples
- Factory is prepared (correct equipment, trained operators)
During Production Inspection (DUPRO)
When 20-30% of production is complete:
- Catch quality issues before full production
- Verify production matches approved sample
- Check workmanship on completed units
- Identify and correct problems while production continues
Pre-Shipment Inspection (PSI)
When 100% of production is complete and packed:
- Random sampling per AQL tables
- Comprehensive quality checks
- Measurement verification
- Packaging and labeling check
- Go/no-go decision for shipment
Container Loading Inspection
During container loading:
- Verify correct quantity loaded
- Check for loading damage
- Verify carton marking and count
- Document with photos
Want to see how Cubic compares to your current forwarder?
AQL Standards and Sampling
AQL (Acceptable Quality Level) defines how many defects are acceptable in a production lot. Understanding AQL is essential for inspection decisions.
What is AQL?
AQL is a statistical sampling method that determines:
- How many units to inspect from a lot
- How many defects trigger pass/fail decision
- Different thresholds for critical, major, and minor defects
Common AQL Levels for Apparel
| Defect Type | Typical AQL | Description |
|---|---|---|
| Critical | 0 | Safety issues, regulatory non-compliance |
| Major | 2.5 | Affects function or salability |
| Minor | 4.0 | Does not affect function, slight appearance issue |
Sample Size Determination
AQL tables determine sample size based on lot size:
| Lot Size | Sample Size (General II) |
|---|---|
| 151-280 | 32 |
| 281-500 | 50 |
| 501-1200 | 80 |
| 1201-3200 | 125 |
| 3201-10000 | 200 |
Defect Classification
- Critical: Needle in garment, wrong fiber content, safety hazard
- Major: Wrong size, significant color variation, functional failure (broken zipper)
- Minor: Slight shade variation, small cosmetic imperfection, minor measurement variance
Common Garment Defects
Understanding common defect types helps focus inspection efforts and communicate issues to factories.
Fabric Defects
- Shade variation: Color differs within garment or between garments
- Fabric flaws: Holes, snags, pulls, runs
- Wrong fabric: Incorrect weight, composition, or hand
- Shrinkage issues: Fabric not properly pre-shrunk
Construction Defects
- Seam issues: Puckering, uneven, skipped stitches, unraveling
- Hem problems: Uneven hem, incorrect length, twisted
- Topstitching: Uneven, crooked, wrong color
- Structural: Twisted garment, asymmetrical, poor alignment
Measurement Defects
- Out of tolerance: Measurement exceeds specified tolerance
- Inconsistent sizing: Same size varies between units
- Wrong size label: Garment doesn't match labeled size
Trim and Finishing Defects
- Missing components: Buttons, zippers, labels missing or incomplete
- Trim defects: Wrong color, poor attachment, poor quality
- Label issues: Wrong content, placement, or missing information
- Pressing: Improper pressing, shine, creasing
Packaging Defects
- Wrong packaging: Incorrect hanger, bag, or folding
- Damaged packaging: Torn polybags, broken hangers
- Labeling: Wrong UPC, missing price tickets
Measurement Control and Fit
Consistent sizing is critical for customer satisfaction and return rates. Measurement control requires clear specifications and consistent verification.
Developing Size Specifications
- Grade rules: How measurements change between sizes
- Tolerance levels: Acceptable variation from spec
- Key measurements: Critical dimensions that define fit
- Secondary measurements: Less critical but still controlled
Typical Measurement Tolerances
| Measurement | Typical Tolerance |
|---|---|
| Chest/Bust | ±1/2 inch |
| Waist | ±1/2 inch |
| Length | ±1/2 inch |
| Sleeve length | ±1/4 inch |
| Neck opening | ±1/4 inch |
Measurement Inspection
- Measure on flat surface using consistent method
- Check multiple sizes per shipment
- Compare to spec, not just to sample
- Document measurement findings
Fit Sessions
For critical products, conduct fit sessions:
- Fit samples on live models
- Evaluate movement, comfort, appearance
- Compare to approved fit sample
- Document any adjustments needed
Third-Party Inspection Services
Third-party inspection companies provide independent quality verification. Understanding when and how to use them maximizes value.
When to Use Third-Party Inspection
- New factory relationships (before trust is established)
- Critical or high-value orders
- History of quality issues with supplier
- Limited internal QC resources
- Need for independent verification
Major Inspection Companies
- SGS, Bureau Veritas, Intertek (global coverage)
- QIMA, Asia Inspection (Asia-focused)
- Regional specialists in specific markets
What Third-Party Inspections Include
- Visual inspection per your specifications
- Measurement verification
- Workmanship evaluation
- Packaging and labeling check
- Detailed report with photos
Inspection Costs
- Typical cost: $200-400 per man-day
- One man-day covers 1-2 standard inspections
- Additional costs for testing, multiple locations
Maximizing Inspection Value
- Provide clear specifications and defect classification
- Supply approved samples for reference
- Define pass/fail criteria clearly
- Review reports promptly and follow up on issues
- Use inspection data to improve supplier performance
Laboratory Testing Requirements
Beyond visual inspection, many garments require laboratory testing for safety and performance.
Common Test Requirements
- Fiber content: Verify actual fiber composition matches labels
- Colorfastness: Resistance to washing, rubbing, light
- Dimensional stability: Shrinkage after washing
- Flammability: Required for sleepwear and children's products
- Physical performance: Tensile strength, pilling, abrasion
Children's Product Testing
CPSIA requires third-party testing for children's products:
- Lead content (100 ppm limit)
- Phthalates (certain products)
- Flammability (sleepwear)
- Small parts (choking hazard)
Testing Timing
- Pre-production: Test fabric before cutting
- Production: Periodic testing during production
- Pre-shipment: Final verification before shipping
Test Reports and Documentation
- Maintain test reports for each production lot
- Keep reports for minimum 5 years
- Have reports available for customs if requested
- Include test report references in import documentation
Supplier Quality Management
Long-term quality improvement requires managing supplier performance systematically.
Supplier Qualification
Before first production:
- Factory audit (social compliance and capability)
- Sample evaluation
- Reference checks with other buyers
- Quality history review
Performance Tracking
Track quality metrics by supplier:
- Inspection pass rate
- Defect rate by type
- Return rate from customers
- Response to quality issues
Corrective Action Process
When quality issues occur:
- Document the issue with evidence
- Communicate clearly to supplier
- Require root cause analysis
- Agree on corrective actions
- Verify implementation
- Monitor for recurrence
Supplier Scorecards
Regular performance reviews:
- Quality score (inspection results, customer returns)
- Delivery score (on-time, complete)
- Responsiveness (communication, issue resolution)
- Improvement trend
Relationship Building
- Invest in long-term relationships with good suppliers
- Provide constructive feedback
- Share quality data and improvement goals
- Recognize and reward quality performance